Santino C.
1/19/2026
I was in Cedarburg for the day and I wanted a quick bite. Sal's Pizza was just up the street and I could not resist. I had a delicious slice and the customary garlic knot. It's always a positive...
Sal's Pizza
$
Closed
(102)
Advertisement
Photos
W63N635 Washington Ave
Cedarburg, WI 53012
Sal's Pizza in Cedarburg, WI, is a New York-style pizzeria with roots in Brooklyn, offering a diverse menu that includes pizza by the slice or pie, calzones, strombolis, and a variety of appetizers. The establishment prides itself on using the freshest local ingredients, with all items made in-house to ensure quality and flavor.
In addition to their signature Sicilian thick crust pizza, Sal's provides options for delivery, dine-in, and carryout, making it a convenient choice for any occasion. Whether you're craving classic flavors or unique specialty pizzas, Sal's Pizza caters to all tastes and preferences.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5(102)
Joseph H.
12/16/2025
My third visit to Sal's Pizza here in Cedarburg. I'm a regular customer of Sal's on Milwaukee's Upper East Side. Very good New York style pizza that you can buy by the slice. When you order a...
Marissa P.
11/13/2025
I was really excited about this spot because of the setup here is reminiscent of getting a slice of pizza in New York City. BUT for over $6 per slice I would say it's not worth it. The pizza...
Ina L.
12/11/2024
Stopped by Sals for a quick slice of pizza as we were walking around downtown. Overall the slice was nothing special, kind of too oily for my liking and the roll was pretty dry with an...
Lacrisha L.
10/23/2024
Me and my friends partook in a bloody Mary pub crawl this past Saturday. After hitting up a couple places a few of us stopped here to grab a slice and continue on the pub crawl. I decided to with...
See a problem?
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement