Tara B.
1/17/2026
Over the past 3 months we have been using this location for group sub orders. They have been awesome fulfilling orders and answering any questions. Huge improvement from last year when we did...
Jimmy John's
$
Closed
(34)
Advertisement
Photos
6921 University Ave
Middleton, WI 53562
We slice our all-natural meats and fresh veggies in-house every day. Our fresh-baked bread is made right here where you can see it, and our house-made tuna salad is fresh every day. The flavor of a ripe tomato, crisp shredded lettuce, combined with fresh-baked bread, fresh-sliced meat and real Hellmann's mayo - that's when the magic happens. Made with love every single day since 1983. That's Jimmy Fresh!
Reviews
2.0(34)
Dean Z.
9/28/2025
Their hours say they're open until 10pm, but they most definitely are not open that late. I drove out of my way to get there before 10pm on Thursday night and they were very much closed.
Thomas T.
3/14/2025
Hard to complain, as I only needed a couple skinny/slim subs. It wasn't busy, so my sandwiches were done promptly. No complaints here, but nothing made this store stand out over others.
Dayna M.
9/14/2024
What happened to this place?! I've been to this location twice in the past year and both times were shockingly bad. Several months ago I placed a pick up order for lunch on a weekday. The place...
David H.
6/11/2024
Terrible. Showed up for Freaky Fast service after a 15min detour. I walked in to find the place completely dark with no power. All the other shops had power. I was told sorry they're closed due to...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement