David G.
12/29/2025
Really good pizza in a super competitive pizza city! I like that they have gotten way more consistent with their pizzas! It shows me that quality over quantity is the secret!
Sexton's Pizza
$$
Closed
(124)
Advertisement
Photos
5460 Franklin St
Hilliard, OH 43026
Sexton's Pizza, located in Hilliard, OH, prides itself on being one of the best pizza destinations in Columbus. Renowned for its hand-tossed dough that is allowed to rise for two days and cooked in stone brick ovens, each pizza promises a crispy crust and mouth-watering flavors.
Offering a wide range of unique specialty pizzas alongside classic favorites like pepperoni, the menu features a variety of creative toppings and sauces prepared from scratch. Committed to quality over quantity, Sexton's Pizza prioritizes freshness and artisan techniques to ensure every slice is crafted to perfection.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5(124)
Juan D.
5/5/2025
Ok. Back again and tried the Kevin Bacon with a side of Hot Honey, Hot Honey wings and a CBC IPA. I'm gonna keep this short. Give me an IV filled with Mike's Hot Honey, plug me in and let me...
Elizabeth Y.
4/6/2025
First time here and found it through barstool pizza reviews. The pizza was really tasty, the best part was the crisp and fresh crust of the pizza! We got the garlic knots as well. They were good...
Dan M.
1/3/2026
Placed an order via DoorDash for a later pickup. Arrived at original pickup time, pickup time changed to 15 minutes later. Was told it'd be a few minutes. After checking again 35 minutes after...
Saphace A.
1/23/2025
I see why some people say this is one of the best pizza places in town! I ordered the East Village (pepperoni with basil), 16" NY style pie. They are known for selling out so I ordered in the...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement