Mrs. Goodman's Baking

$
Closed
yelp logo

(107)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

901 High St
Worthington, OH 43085
+1 (614) 888-7437
http://www.mrsgoodmans.com
At Mrs. Goodman's, we're known for our beautifully decorated (and indescribably delicious) special occasion cakes, but we also bake delectable cookies, brownies, cupcakes, scones and pies to help you enjoy life's little moments.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5107 reviews
Photo of Eric C.
Eric C.
8/17/2025

Update - I got another birthday cake, but this time customized. Filled out the order form online and was communicating with the bakery quickly. We went back-and-forth between fondant and...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jenna D.
Jenna D.
12/22/2025

Wow! A friend dropped off a box of cookies as a post surgery treat. Might be the best peanut butter cookies of all time. Kids and spouse enjoyed chocolate chip, m&m and oatmeal raisin as well....

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Hannah B.
Hannah B.
9/7/2024

They did a great job with a custom order. I had 2 dozen cookies with different designs. It ended up being $4 a cookie, which seems pricey, but the cookies were large and very delicious. My guests...

Read more on Yelp
Taylor R.
9/23/2025

Love this place!!! My whole family always gets their birthday cakes from here and we love stopping in and saying hi to the staff and picking up some goodies. Highly recommend anything almond...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Amy S.
Amy S.
9/24/2025

Mrs. Goodman's is amazing! From the delectable cakes, big soft cookies, gooey pecan rolls, fudgie brownies, and so much more. Can't go wrong with anything they offer!

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Cookie Bouquets
Cookies, Eating places, Computer equipment and electronics, mail order

Cookie Bouquets

$
Cookie Bouquets, based in Columbus, OH, has been family owned and operated since 1983, using a secret butter cookie recipe passed down from Grandma Evelyn. They specialize in baking fresh, homemade cookies that can be customized for any occasion, offering a range of products from cookie bouquets to gift baskets and logo cookies. Customers can also request cookies with personal photos printed using food-safe ink. With a commitment to quality, Cookie Bouquets provides a variety of treats including classic iced butter cookies and chocolate frosted brownies. Their services cater to celebrations big and small, ensuring that there is something sweet for everyone in the family. Known for their expertise in custom cookies, they serve customers not just in Columbus, but nationwide. Generated from the website
Sammy's New York Bagels
Delicatessen (eating places), Bagels

Sammy's New York Bagels

57
•
$
"Excellent bagels. We especially like the onion bagels, but the garlic and everything bagels are not too far behind."
photo of Ted B.
Golden Donuts & Diner
Eating places, Diner, Doughnuts

Golden Donuts & Diner

65
•
$
"We went for the first time after reading about this being a "hidden gem". It doesn't look like much from the exterior, but the food and service were both very good. The portions were very large,..."
United States›Ohio›Worthington›Mrs. Goodman's Baking

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement