Kelsey S.
1/7/2024
I am embarrassed by how often I order from here. Their food is delicious! Salads, pizza, Stromboli, subs... everything I've tried from here has been great! I live nearby so I pick up often. The...
Castello Pizza
Closed
(22)
Advertisement
Photos
2577 Indianola Ave
Columbus, OH 43202
Castello Pizza, located in Columbus, OH, offers a unique blend of New York-style pizza with a crispy Ohio-style crust, making it a local favorite. The restaurant prides itself on using authentic ingredients and providing fast, courteous service to its customers.
With a menu featuring favorites like mozzarella sticks and chicken parmesan, Castello Pizza has garnered rave reviews for its consistent quality and flavor. Patrons often describe it as the most authentic Italian pizza in Columbus, making it a go-to spot for pizza lovers in the area.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0(22)
Dan F.
1/11/2025
Wanted to like this place because it's so close and local but my last three experiences have been really bad. The pizza is always thin and super greasy in the middle and it's impossible to eat...
Taco Q.
8/26/2023
I ordered delivery tonight- ten boneless wings, a side of fries, and a can of root beer. It set me back $25 and it's some of the worst food I've had in Columbus. The wings are burnt to a crispy,...
Sarah W.
12/22/2024
The best pizza starts with the best crust! The crust here is amazing! My order is always ready on time, too!
Emily J.
5/2/2023
This is seriously the best pizza in columbus. The margherita pizza is the bomb. Oreo cake is good but not my fave. #1 for pizza for sure though!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement