Neil G.
11/12/2025
Always great food and great service! Thin crust NY style is very good. Other menu items like calzones look good too, but I always get the pizza! Highly recommended!
Brooklyn Pizza
$
Open
(169)
Advertisement
Photos
240 N Liberty St
Powell, OH 43065
Established by a Sicilian immigrant in New York, Brooklyn Pizza in Powell, OH, carries forward a rich family tradition of crafting authentic New York style pizza. With a foundation built on generations of baking experience, they offer a variety of pizza and Italian dishes, drawing upon traditional techniques and recipes passed down through the family.
Known for their top-notch pizza and casual dining atmosphere, Brooklyn Pizza has become a local favorite, offering everything from classic cheese slices to specialty pies. Guests appreciate the quality, flavorful options, and the welcoming service, making it a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts in the area.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0169 reviewsBeth S.
12/30/2025
Anthony's Brooklyn Pizza is the best New York pizza in Columbus! It is always fresh and hot out of the oven. The sauce is perfect and the toppings are generous. It is the only pizza we eat!
Boogers C.
8/24/2025
Been now going here for close to 4 years and yup, still consistently great, right ingredients, right cut, right shape, they know what a slice is, understand sarcasm, I feel like you get the right...
Jenna D.
2/2/2025
Ordered two pies online. Pick up was fast after floating in cartoon character-style on the smell from the parking lot. Employees were very nice but most importantly the pizza crushed. The plain...
Lindsay W.
11/3/2024
I'm not even sure how to word this other than HELL YEAH. I'm from New York and it's impossible to find good NY style pizza and this guy nailed it. He's a Long Island native and he knows exactly...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement