Anthony G.
7/6/2025
Happy to review the new Black Sheep, where Maggie's eatery used to be. We would routinely come to Maggie's. Happy to find out one of Maggie's staff is the owner of Black Sheep. The inside looks...
The BlackSheep at Miller Place
Closed
(18)
Advertisement
Photos
465 Route 25A
Miller Place, NY 11764
Black Sheep is a locally owned eatery in Miller Place, NY, celebrated for its creative American Fusion Comfort Food and a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant prides itself on providing a unique dining experience, whether for a casual lunch, a hearty dinner, or a delightful weekend brunch, all crafted with fresh ingredients and thoughtful preparation.
In addition to its dining offerings, Black Sheep caters to special occasions, providing tailored services for events ranging from birthday parties to corporate gatherings. With a focus on helping customers create unforgettable experiences, the team is dedicated to ensuring each event reflects the individuality and joy of embracing the extraordinary.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
5.018 reviews
Riley S.
8/9/2025
Walked in with my husband and it had just opened for the day about 20 - 30 mins before. There was no one there but the workers. They were very nice and greeted us and told us to sit where we would...
G M.
11/15/2025
A well thought menu with a lot of different items...and absolutely delicious food huge servings!!! Very nice people too....our new favorite eatery...
Leesa E.
11/25/2025
The best bagels ever! They're tasty and the perfect consistency. I highly recommend Black Sheep Bagels.
Paula S.
11/8/2025
This place was great!! We walked in with our 10 month old and they came right out with a highchair and toys/ coloring books for our son! They were super friendly, and the restaurant was nice and...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement