Nick F.
8/10/2021
We stopped here for ice cream and Italian Ices after having lunch at the Inn. The salted caramel ice cream was very good. And the Luigi's ices are one of my favorites. Friendly service. I didn't...
Pizza Shack Of Kismet
$
Closed
(23)
Advertisement
Photos
59 E Lighthouse Walk
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Pizza Shack of Kismet is a popular pizza restaurant located in Kismet, NY, offering a variety of comfort food options for lunch and dinner, including their renowned ice cream with real chunks of strawberry and cheesecake.
With a casual atmosphere and outdoor seating available, Pizza Shack is a favorite spot among tourists and locals alike, providing a quick and delicious dining experience for solo diners or families with kids.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.023 reviews
Elizabeth P.
9/14/2025
Save yourself the extra steps and go elsewhere. Pizza is just bread with cheese and sauce no real flavor. For the prices you get nothing but the want to go elsewhere and grab something else to eat...
Steven G.
8/2/2025
The original "Pizza Shack" over by the ferry was 100% better. This is NY, come on! OK pizza very expensive $90 for 2 pies...got the order wrong, oops forgot the pepperoni? Sorry, added it while...
Linda D.
8/23/2020
Don't expect great selection of ice cream or and ices. The pizza is not NY style pizza, especially for why they charge but it's ok. Towards the summer evening, especially weekends a lot of...
Andrea O.
9/12/2020
When you get off your ferry, this will be the first business you come across to your right close to the souvenir shop. Although, I only noticed it on my way back. I do not have any complaints for...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement