Pie Pie Pizza

122 reviews

+1 (212) 222-4022

Website

Photos

Cheese, buffalo chicken, and chicken bacon ranch

Pepperoni slice, Ricotta slice, Chicken Bacon Ranch slice

Pie Pie Original Pizza Pie with pepperoni

Chris beer and thinner than the usual New York pie. Overall not bad. (Pepperoni Pizza Pie with olives)

924 Columbus Ave

New York, NY 10025

+1 (212) 222-4022

http://piepiepizza.com

History

Started in the pizza business 25 years ago.

Specialties

At Pie Pie Pizza we make all our pies with love daily. Starting with our fresh dough which we allow to ferment slowly giving our dough a deep and distinctive flavor. We then add only the best real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese and italian plum tomatoes for our sauce. Always served hot and with a smile we invite you to try Pie Pie Pizza and enjoy!

Find related places

Places To Eat

Fast Food

Pizza

Reviews

4.0122 reviews

Tom U.

12/16/2024

Change of address was a bit far, it's still posted but still a walk. Pizza was good, if you don't want a whole pie, it's $2.50. Got pizza on time and ordered ahead on Yelp. It's a cozy spot. A...

Read more on Yelp

Dallas A.

8/27/2023

The flavor of Pie Pie is solid, and the employees were friendly enough, but the pizza looked like it had been sitting out for an hour+ when we visited last night. Though the reheat can somewhat...

Read more on Yelp

Charlie S.

10/31/2024

I am a real fan of the Supreme! Absolutely delicious! Delivery was fast and Pie arrived hot. Keep it up, Pie Pie!

Read more on Yelp