Jennifer H.
11/29/2025
How have I lived 5 min from this place and only tried their pizza for the first time just recently!? I know now why they were top rated! SO many options for unique slices but honestly, their plain...
Pappardelle's Pizzeria
$
Closed
(172)
Advertisement
Photos
554 Stewart Ave
Bethpage, NY 11714
Serving robust flavors and hearty portions, we offer consistently delicious brick-oven style pizza with the best homemade dough and sauce in town! Serving specialty and gourmet pizzas, we also have a large selection of pastas, seafood, calzones, and more! An authentic Italian restaurant, Pappardelle's always has fresh, delicious entrees and offers a gluten free menu.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5172 reviews
Lenny F.
8/10/2025
Last time at this hit n miss unpredictable place. Veal cutlet parm with sauce on side. Sauce was SOUR! Wth. No cheese on it! Totally flavorless. Should have never ordered from here.waste of money....
Sarah S.
7/30/2025
!!Save your money and go elsewhere!! If there is a problem with the food, the owner is defensive and has a HUGE attitude. Dear Owner, I think it is time to pass this business off to someone...
Lauren R.
4/2/2025
I'm lucky enough to work close by, so I come here fairly frequently. The ambience brings back so many warm memories of classic pizzerias with an admirable array of pizza options. I tried the...
Arthur D.
12/13/2025
Best Pizza I have had in NY. Yes, better than the city. The crew is friendly and service is fast. I stop here every time I am in Long Island.
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement