Caitlyn G.
8/15/2025
This ice cream place is super cute and quirky inside! The flavor creations they have are out of this world- the Ube Marshmallow was DELICIOUS!
OddFellows Ice Cream Co.
$$
Closed
(177)
Advertisement
Photos
60 Water St
Brooklyn, NY 11201
OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is a unique ice cream shop nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, NY. They offer a variety of handcrafted ice cream flavors made with high-quality ingredients.
With a focus on creativity and innovation, OddFellows Ice Cream Co. provides a delightful experience for ice cream enthusiasts looking to indulge in artisanal frozen treats.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0177 reviews
Brandon Y.
8/14/2025
When I heard about the Breast Milk Ice cream collab that they were having with Frida, I had to come by. I'm an open-minded guy so I'm totally into trying anything and most of us HAVE had breast...
Katie-Ann F.
8/8/2025
I've always wanted to try Odd Fellows because of their variety of unique flavors! When I came with a friend, they were promoting their collab with Frida, selling "Breast Milk" ice cream. With a...
Sarah T.
12/10/2025
The ice cream was good. so it's got that going for it- however this is not the Odd fellows of years prior with many more flavors. Maybe it's just this branch but I needed more options to mull...
Gab G.
6/26/2025
Prob your best option for ice cream in the dumbo area. Pistachio soft serve in a waffle cone was perfect (and huge). Much better than Brooklyn ice cream factory.
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement