Svyatoslav D.
12/13/2025
This place is so fire, I would 100% recommend, very nice staff and quick results, nice aesthetic.
Nick's Tomato Pie
$
Closed
(70)
Advertisement
Photos
109 Walton St
Syracuse, NY 13202
Nick's Tomato Pie is a pizzeria known for its variety of pizza options, including specialties like garlic pizza and pepperoni. Customers have reported mixed experiences, highlighting both the quality of certain pizzas and areas for improvement in others. The establishment places an emphasis on great customer service to enhance the dining experience.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5(70)
Stephanie N.
1/23/2026
Amazing pizza & great service with a smile!! Placed an order online thru their website & ordered for pickup. This place speaks pizza vibes! I ordered a large cheese & pep pizza, medium wings extra...
Nichole K.
7/11/2025
We happened to stumble upon Nick's Tomato Pie after visiting the MOST to check out the new Nature Photography exhibit and what a fantastic surprise it turned out to be! We came by on a Thursday...
Tina L.
1/17/2026
Pizza and wings were amazing! Michael Watson was amazing. Great customer service. The whole order was cooked to perfection!
Phil H.
10/11/2024
Conveniently located in the heart of downtown, this pizza place is only populated after 10pm and for good reason: the pizza is mediocre and staff bullies guests. Probably will not be coming back...
See a problem?
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement