J M.
9/19/2025
Large portions. We all had bagel sandwiches for a late breakfast. Pretty loud though inside due to the hard surfaces.
Carol's Cafe
$
Open
(64)
Advertisement
Photos
217 E 51st St
New York, NY 10022
Carol's Cafe is a charming eatery located within a picturesque park in the heart of Manhattan. Nestled between a cardiologist's office and a synagogue, the cafe offers a relaxing atmosphere highlighted by a lovely waterfall and lush greenery. Visitors can enjoy a selection of delicious food while taking in the park's serene surroundings.
This unique spot serves as an urban oasis, providing a welcome escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. Though the food is well-regarded, customers should be mindful of the posted prices. Overall, Carol's Cafe is a delightful place to unwind and savor good food in a beautiful setting.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.564 reviews
Zac M.
9/5/2025
This is a small service counter. The food was pretty mid, but fairly inexpensive. The seating was super nice in an outdoor area with a waterfall.
Jim C.
6/25/2025
We stayed at POD51 across the street and found this gem! A small urban park with a lovely waterfall feature. Carol's classic western omelette breakfast with a smoothie was great and inexpensive!
Sandra H.
7/30/2024
Unexpected gem in a park-like setting. The only thing visible from the street is the sandwich board. the food was good quality, amazing because it was produced in a space the size of a walk-in closet
Emi G.
11/22/2022
Incredible! Tucked away, with a beautiful waterfall and quaint seating, Carol's is a hidden gem! The food is so reasonable and absolutely delicious. Went for Essa-Bagel and the line was too long....
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement