George G.
11/13/2025
Every time we visit this pizza place, it feels like we are transported straight to Italy, with its warm atmosphere and authentic flavors filling the air. The traditional Italian cuisine is crafted...
Reservoir Restaurant
$$
Closed
(208)
Advertisement
Photos
106 W South Orange Ave
South Orange, NJ 07079
Reservoir Restaurant is a beloved, family-owned Italian eatery in South Orange, NJ, known for its delicious pizza and sausage. With a rich history dating back to 1935, this old-school restaurant offers a friendly atmosphere that caters to families, featuring a "Make Your Own Pizza Night" on Mondays and a private party room for up to 45 guests.
Founded by the Agnellino family, Reservoir has been a staple in the community, attracting a diverse clientele that includes locals, politicians, and longtime regulars. Situated conveniently near the train station, this cash-only establishment continues to uphold its traditional pizza recipe while offering a wide selection of toppings for both dine-in and take-out customers.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0208 reviews
Matthew W.
9/11/2025
Had an awful experience tonight. Sat down at 5:45pm and ordered a pie, plain pasta with butter for my kids, shrimp marinara over broccoli, and penne vodka with chicken and mushrooms. By 6:45pm,...
Shantae K.
8/8/2025
I rarely leave negative reviews, but I feel it's important to share what happened during my recent visit to this restaurant. I came here with my children expecting a pleasant meal, but...
Heather L.
5/18/2025
In a quest for Jersey's great pizza, we tried this spot. First, love the old school vibes and ambiance. It feels classic old Jersey. BYOB and cash only. The food: we tried Tony's salad...
Ritesh M.
4/5/2025
Firstly know this place is cash or check ONLY. Plan accordingly- although there is an ATM on site. Hopped in here on a Friday evening without reservations and were lucky to get seated...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement