Stacy T.
8/15/2025
Great NY style pizza. Very friendly and a very spacious dining room. We ordered the 14" manhattan margarita and 14" with green olives (don't see that very often) mushrooms, pepperoni & Italian...
AJ's NY Pizzeria
$
Open
(231)
Advertisement
Photos
301 Poyntz Ave
Manhattan, KS 66502
Pizza by the Slice, Salads, Fresh Ingredients and Great Customer Service
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0231 reviews
Susan R.
7/20/2025
Visiting family in the area, and after spending the day at Fort Riley, i decided to check out Manhattan, KS, aka The Little Apple. Took my Italian-American Boston self to AJ's to check out what...
Travis T.
12/1/2025
The garlic knots were delicious and so was the pizza despite the pizza sauce being a bit sweeter than what've I liked to be. The calzone was delicious and it was worth the 15-minute wait. The...
Rich F.
12/9/2025
AJ's is always great, my local go-to for pizza. Love the atmosphere there as well, staff is always friendly and prompt.
Elton M.
10/14/2025
Great pizza. Defiantly a stop when in Manhappiness or at least take it to go and have when we get home
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement