Eileen S.
3/10/2014
I used to live in Indiana, and frequented John's for many years before moving to Maryland. Now, whenever I visit home, I always make it a point to go to John's AT LEAST once, if not more times! I...
John's Pizzeria
$$
Closed
(40)
Advertisement
Photos
1209 Sheffield Ave
Dyer, IN 46311
John’s Pizzeria is a beloved family-owned Italian restaurant serving the Dyer, Indiana community for over 80 years. Known for handcrafted pizzas, fresh homemade bread, classic Italian favorites, every meal is prepared with care using quality ingredients and time-honored family recipes. With welcoming dine-in spaces, easy carry-out, delivery, and catering options, John’s offers something for every occasion, from crispy appetizers and hearty sandwiches to savory pastas and signature pies. Whether you’re gathering with family, celebrating a special moment, or grabbing a delicious meal on the go, this local pizzeria delivers timeless flavor, warm hospitality, and unforgettable dining experiences that keep generations of customers coming back.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0(40)
Tammy A.
8/10/2025
Hands down the worst food we were ever served in a restaurant! 1st and last time we will visit. Appetizer: Fried Zucchini - a soggy mess! Yet burnt as well. Obviously dropped into the fryer...
Hanna N.
9/7/2023
We have ordered from John's several times and love their pizza. Sometimes while we wait for our pizza we will sit at the bar and get some drinks and an appetizer. Always great service and friendly...
Laura P.
5/2/2024
Food, service and atmosphere very good. Bar dining just as great, and nice family business. Highly recommend!
Dan R.
3/26/2019
The pizza and pasta are consistently good. Always seems to be a special of the day We enjoyed $2.00 yuenling goldens...tasty
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement