Katherine A.
11/2/2025
I'm a Jimmy John's fan! I love everything about the subs, bread, sandwiches. Yesterday, we ordered a bunch of sandwiches to go to feed the family. The order was perfect as were the sandwiches....
Jimmy John's
$
Closed
(39)
Advertisement
Photos
2810 E 116th St Ste 140
Carmel, IN 46033
We slice our all-natural meats and fresh veggies in-house every day. Our fresh-baked bread is made right here where you can see it, and our house-made tuna salad is fresh every day. The flavor of a ripe tomato, crisp shredded lettuce, combined with fresh-baked bread, fresh-sliced meat and real Hellmann's mayo - that's when the magic happens. Made with love every single day since 1983. That's Jimmy Fresh!
Also at this address
Reviews
2.5(39)
Dave M.
12/21/2025
Not a great experience, would not recommend. Bread was old, sandwich had 3 slices of meat on it, and service was lackadaisical.
Debra T.
2/11/2025
I ordered the sandwich with no bread that had lettuce wrapped around it. It was an Italian sandwich. It was absolutely tasteless. The meat had no taste!
Barbara F.
8/25/2023
I have been living in Carmel for 20+ years and first the first time stopped in to this Jimmy John's. They are located near the Starbucks which I go to frequently but I don't typically buy or order...
Nicole S.
2/10/2019
Gotta like a Jimmy John's, because they almost always have a drive-thru. This comes in handy on days like today, when it was snowing but I wanted a sub sandwich. No problem: Let's drive to Jimmy...
Owner verified
See a problem?
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement