Susan E.
12/11/2025
I had the Margherita pizza with thin crust, garlic, and a drizzle of good olive oil--it was absolutely delicious! The flavors were fresh and balanced, and the crust was perfectly crisp. What made...
Papa Luigi's
$
Open
(23)
Advertisement
Photos
143 SE Highway 349
Old Town, FL 32680
Old Town's own family take out pizzeria! Family owned and operated we offer a variety of pizzas, pastas, salads, and sides. Our doors are open to all of you, our friends!
Reviews
4.523 reviews
Thomas B.
12/3/2025
My first visit at Papa Luigi's pizza . Small place with a couple table . We ordered a 16 inch Margarita Pie and it was very delicious. I love thin crust pizza and enjoyed every bite. Papa Luigi is...
Sheila M.
7/5/2025
Thin crust New York style.. great crust and sauce. Nice People. It's very small inside so plan around that. Definitely best in town .. skip that fast food and give it a try.
David M.
10/25/2025
Stayed in the area for a few days and tried the local Pizza Shop. And yes, if we're in the area again we'll get another pie there.
Rebekha L.
10/20/2023
Great fast service, easy ordering and friendly staff. Miles better than H*ngry H*wie's LOLZ. We'll for sure be making the 30 minute drive to try more menu items.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement