Tony A.
6/23/2025
First stop every year once we make it to the island. Smoked Fish Dip and Ceviche are top recommendations!
Capt Anthonys Seafood
Closed
(31)
Advertisement
Photos
107 Spring Ave
Anna Maria, FL 34216
Captain Anthony's Seafood in Anna Maria, FL is renowned for offering the freshest and largest stone crab claws available. With a dedication to quality and a commitment to providing top-notch seafood, Captain Anthony ensures that each order is delivered with the utmost freshness and flavor.
Customers from all over, including those in Florida and beyond, rave about the succulent and delicious stone crab claws provided by Captain Anthony. Whether you're a longtime seafood enthusiast or new to the world of stone crab, Captain Anthony's Seafood is the go-to destination for a truly exceptional dining experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.531 reviews
Paul M.
11/15/2025
What a big disappointment! We ordered the ceviche, and it tasted absolutely terrible. The flavors were off, the texture wasn't right, and it was nothing like what you'd expect for the price....
mark b.
4/26/2025
The Shack is Back! When we stay on AMI, we always visit Captain Anthony's as fish simply does not get fresher than this. I was worried they might not be there after the hurricanes, but they are...
Kelly D.
3/6/2025
We got a lb of grouper and Captain Anthony's Signature dip. Both were to die for and extremely fresh!!! Wish I had a picture of the dip but it was so good we ate it before I could get a picture....
Jim R.
1/31/2021
We were down in Anna Maria Florida and had to get some fresh stone crab (love it) and located this tiny shack near the beach that sell amazingly fresh seafood. It's not much to look at just a...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement