We have come here every year for 18 years. Great pizza. Will be busy on Saturday night at checkin. Their menus change after 4pm to just apps/salads and pizzas. Lunch has wraps
Bj's Pizza & Subs
(261)
Advertisement
Photos
Also at this address
Reviews
(261)
Surprisingly delicious for an island pizza joint! Dough had a perfect hint of sweetness, and an amazing crunch-and-chew. We got a classic pep to go, and it was ready in just about 15 minutes...
2.5 stars. It tastes like what I remember Pizza Hut tasting like as a kid. Tons of toppings, super heavy and greasy, a thick white bready crust. This is not pizza to write home about, though it...
We of course had pizza our first night here! It was great as usual! Turn days are super busy so we expected a wait! Then we got pizza and jalapeño chips another night! It was terrific! Be cautious...
Amazing crust and toppings. Nice cheese pull on the Margherita pizza!! Price not crazy either. Next time on the island we will likely be here again.
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement





