Stephanie S.
12/24/2025
Bayside Gourmet is seriously the BEST!! I lived across the street for 8 months and wow wow wow. The pasta is just incredible. I'm obsessed with their massive chicken parm, there's soo much melted...
Bayside Gourmet
$$
Closed
(560)
Advertisement
Photos
82758 Overseas Hwy
Islamorada, FL 33036
Bayside Gourmet is a family-owned and operated restaurant located in Islamorada, Florida, offering a diverse menu that features both classic and contemporary dishes. Committed to quality, the establishment prides itself on using the freshest ingredients, with all menu items prepared by hand in their kitchen.
Guests can enjoy their meals either indoors or on the patio, and the restaurant also provides free delivery within the local area starting in the evening. In addition to a robust food menu, Bayside Gourmet serves a selection of craft beer and wine to complement the dining experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5560 reviews
William G.
12/18/2025
Very friendly service and attentive. Food was delicious but really loved the key lime pie We ate outside on the patio and nice ambiance Yes, recommend this for everyone
Angie A.
12/25/2025
The pizza was so good! We had the margarita pizza. The other thing I liked was they have Coke products. The carrot cake was amazing, but I really wasn't impressed with the key lime pie. Service...
Meghan W.
12/25/2024
We were pleasantly surprised by this unassuming roadside spot. From the front it doesn't look like much - tucked in next to a sporting good and CBD/week shop. The outside was lovely with a cozy...
Duncan G.
12/22/2024
My beautiful wife & I are vacationing and for our first night we decided to try this establishment. We are very glad we did! We enjoyed the outdoor seating. My wife really liked the muffuletta...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement