Paul C.
8/4/2025
I went to Tortugas for lunch. I had a slice of Hawaii thin crust pizza. The single slice is about $12 but it is large! Like twice the size I was expecting. I think it is more like a quarter of a...
Tortugas Pizza
$
Closed
(130)
Advertisement
Photos
1304 2nd Ave S
Birmingham, AL 35233
Tortugas Pizza, with locations in Hoover and Birmingham's Southside, is a celebrated pizzeria known for its exceptional Chicago-style stuffed pizza. Recognized by various local publications and voted as the best pizza by readers of Hoover Sun and Hoover’s Magazine for multiple consecutive years, the establishment has firmly established itself as a favorite among pizza enthusiasts in the region.
In addition to its accolades, Tortugas Pizza has earned a spot in numerous food-related lists, including being featured in "100 Dishes To Eat In Alabama Before You Die." The restaurant is also known for its catering services, making it a popular choice for events and gatherings throughout Birmingham.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.5130 reviews
Bill D.
11/18/2025
Great tasting and hot pizza Takes a little time but it's worth the wait. Pizza is definitely like the classic Chicago pizzas I've had in the Windy City.
K M.
12/5/2025
Nice pie, great service. I'll be eating there again. Reviewed needs at least 85 characters.
Mindi F.
9/19/2025
Chicago style deep dish is not my top choice for pizza style. To me it is almost like pizza cake and too much bread. Tortuga's may have changed my opinion though! The Tortuga's is very good. It is...
Jamie J.
4/8/2025
Our favorite casual pizza spot! We're always craving it and have to grab it when next door at Good People. We prefer their thin crust pizza. It's not traditional and thicker than most. They LOAD...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement